Comparing energy performance requirements for appliances from country to country is difficult because of variations in product definitions, misaligned energy test procedures, and divergent efficiency metrics. This complex landscape can prevent policymakers from identifying or adopting global best practices in standards and labels (S&L). It can also present barriers to the proliferation of highly energy-efficient products.
S&L policies are built on a series of technical foundations: product definitions, test procedures, efficiency metrics, and performance levels. Policymakers can increase alignment of product policies by improving the alignment of any of these building blocks. Approximately 18 products are currently comparable across major economies: they either have internationally aligned test procedures or have been the subject of a benchmarking study that establishes robust conversion factors among divergent test procedures. This paper discusses how the European Union (EU) compares to other major economies in product coverage for a set of 100 products and in policy stringency for these 18 comparable products. The paper also examines the costs and benefits of increasing the coverage and stringency of S&L policies in Europe to match world best levels.
For those products whose S&L policies cannot currently be compared, this paper discusses concrete opportunities for increased alignment of the technical foundations or building blocks that underlie product policy, with a focus on implications for the EU. It builds on a study conducted by The Policy Partners for CLASP, which presents the largest and most comprehensive comparison of minimum energy performance standards (MEPS) and energy labels ever compiled. It covers nine major economies Australia, China, the European Union, India, Indonesia, Mexico, Russia, South Africa and the United States and more than 100 products across eight different product areas. The analysis describes which product policies are comparable across economies, which are not, and which could be.
You may like this additional Standards research
Integrating Appliance Efficiency into Nationally Determined Contributions
This report investigates the inclusion of appliance efficiency in Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) and advises governments on how they can best leverage ambitious appliance efficiency policies when revising climate commitments.
Farewell to Fluorescent Lighting: How a Phaseout Can Cut Mercury Pollution, Protect the Climate, and Save Money
This study finds that drop-in LED replacement lamps are available for all common linear fluorescent tubes, pin-based compact fluorescent lamps, and specialty applications in the US.
Study to Evaluate Online Energy Labelling Compliance in the EU
E-commerce is steadily growing in the EU, and numerous websites offer energy-using products for sale. In this study, CLASP and our partners assessed the proper display of appliance energy labels and related information on websites. The study covers six EU Member States: Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, Germany, France, and Slovakia.
Revising the Brazilian Labeling Program for Refrigerators: Lessons from the European Union and Thailand
Brazil's INMETRO is currently considering modifications to the National Label for Energy Conservation (ENCE) for refrigerators. CLASP studies the experiences of the European Union (EU) and Thailand in including additional labeling categories and provides key insights.
Development of Efficiency Policy for Ultra High Definition Televisions in India
The Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) and CLASP worked with Environmental Design Solutions (EDS) to make a comprehensive assessment of the Indian UHD television market through primary and secondary research to formulate a comparative energy efficiency labeling standard for UHD televisions.