Study to Evaluate Online Energy Labelling Compliance in the EU
Fill out the form below to activate file downloads
You can now download the files related to this report above.
Juraj Krivošík, SEVEn, The Energy Efficiency Center, Czech Republic
Pia Westphalen, Vores Bureau, Denmark
Edouard Toulouse, Consultant, France
Quality Assurance by Sophie Attali, SoWatt, France
The onset of the COVID-19 pandemic in early 2020 accelerated a shift in online appliance shopping & purchases.
The increasing importance of online sales
The shift to e-commerce has increased the importance of ensuring compliance with efficiency labelling rules in online contexts to benefit consumers and industry.
Recent research indicates there are low levels of compliance with EU energy labelling regulations in online retail. For example, the January 2020 Special Report of the European Court of Auditors noted that 57% of the inspected products sold online were not labelled accurately or at all.
CLASP and our study team conducted this research to address these mounting concerns, document the state of online energy labelling compliance, investigate the causes of non-compliance, and make recommendations for improvement.
Research scope and methodology
Our study involved online research and a survey of selected stakeholders. The online research covered websites selling refrigerators, washing machines, dishwashers, televisions and lamps. It covered 72 online retail sites and price comparison websites in Belgium, Czech Republic, Denmark, France, Germany, and Slovakia. We surveyed 33 individuals from online retailers, retailer associations, supplier associations (national and EU level) and market surveillance authorities.
Types and frequency of non-compliance
The most frequent non-compliance issues were related to:
- location of the energy label or nested display
- the format and size of the graphic
- the availability of the mandatory product information sheet (product fiche)
- absence of labelling information on some page types (catalogue, basket, comparator).
The evaluation of the practices on price-comparison websites – which have no legal duty and limited labelling information but are highly relevant to consumers – showed low alignment with energy labelling requirements.
The study establishes a typology of the cases of non-compliance encountered during the research – availability, readability, accuracy and additional website mentions. It presents a quantitative and qualitative assessment of the level of compliance observed during the monitoring. Additionally, our study team developed recommendations to increase online labelling compliance by retailers. We categorize those recommendations as informational, organisational, technical or regulatory solutions and propose additional research and follow-up activities.
Watch this recording of a webinar we hosted to present the findings of the study and recommendations to improve the EU situation and, more broadly, to design efficient online labelling schemes.
You may like this additional Labeling research
Integrating Appliance Efficiency into Nationally Determined Contributions
This report investigates the inclusion of appliance efficiency in Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) and advises governments on how they can best leverage ambitious appliance efficiency policies when revising climate commitments.
Air Conditioner Labeling in Thailand: Key Findings and Recommendations
This Policy Brief presents findings from an evaluation of the Electricity Generation Authority for Thailand (EGAT) No. 5 air conditioning (AC) energy label and provides recommendations to enhance the labels' impact in driving the transition to higher-efficiency products.
Revising the Brazilian Labeling Program for Refrigerators: Lessons from the European Union and Thailand
Brazil's INMETRO is currently considering modifications to the National Label for Energy Conservation (ENCE) for refrigerators. CLASP studies the experiences of the European Union (EU) and Thailand in including additional labeling categories and provides key insights.
Development of Efficiency Policy for Ultra High Definition Televisions in India
The Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) and CLASP worked with Environmental Design Solutions (EDS) to make a comprehensive assessment of the Indian UHD television market through primary and secondary research to formulate a comparative energy efficiency labeling standard for UHD televisions.
India Air Compressor Policy Report
CLASP worked with PwC India to conduct comprehensive technology and market assessments for air compressors in India, to inform efficiency standards development and a labeling program. Using both surveys and in-person interviews of manufacturers and their associations, we examined the air compressor market in order to understand product segmentation, projected growth rates, and prevalent technologies.
Transitional Test Method for Ecodesign and Energy Labelling requirements for Electronic Displays
Transitional Test Method sets out a measurement methodology that can be freely used by manufacturers and importers of electronic displays to assess compliance with two recent European regulations.