European Testing Study finds LED Performance Out-paces Expectations
Fill out the form below to activate file downloads
You can now download the files related to this report above.
Lighting has a tremendous impact on our quality of life and our productivity. Artificial illumination extends the productive day, and enables people to work in enclosed space where there is no natural light. Lighting also consumes resources, however, and now accounts for 15% of global energy consumption and 5% of worldwide greenhouse gas emissions. With the advent of light-emitting diode (LED) technology, consumers can access high-quality lighting products at a reduced energy cost and with fewer environmental impacts, particularly when compared to tungsten filament-based technologies such as incandescent and halogen lamps.
The following study, co-authored by CLASP, the governments of Sweden and Belgium, and eceee, presents test results from 170 LED lamps that were purchased in the European market in August and September 2014. The testing measured the efficacy, colour, light distribution pattern, warm-up time, flicker, and other critical quality parameters that are important to consumers. Initial findings after 100 hours of testing were released in November 2014, and an update following 1000 hours of testing was made available in March 2015.
Due to unforeseen market circumstances described in the study, the European Commission proposed a two-year delay to Stage 6 of regulation EC No 244/2009. Stage 6 would remove inefficient (energy label D-class) halogen lamps from the European market in 2016, in favour of efficient technologies such as CFLs and LED lamps (which are energy label class A, A+ and A++). To ensure that European consumers would have access to affordable LED lamps when D-class halogens are no longer available, the Commission proposed a delay to Stage 6 to allow more time for the European LED market to mature. According to this study’s test results, however, LED lamps in Europe are already three to five years ahead of the projected price and energy performance levels that were predicted by the Commission’s consultants in 2013 (see VHK/VITO report). Furthermore, following 1,000 hours of testing, this study finds that most of the lamps being evaluated (15 of the 17 models) meet the Commission’s LED quality requirements.
The market for LED lamps in Europe is moving much faster than previously expected – 50% of the LED lamps tested in this study already exceed the anticipated 2016 price and performance levels. One 2014 LED lamp tested already exceeds the anticipated 2018 level on efficacy and the 2020 level on price. Overall, the clear-glass LED lamps purchased for this study in September 2014 are 11% cheaper, and almost 30% more efficient, than expected.
This study was co-authored by Peter Bennich of the Swedish Energy Agency, Bram Soenen of the Belgian Ministry for Health, Food Chain Safety and the Environment, Michael Scholand of CLASP, and Nils Borg of eceee. Testing was conducted by Christopher Silfvenius and Jonas Pettersson at the Swedish Energy Agency.
Follow the Policymaking Process:
- eceee, 244/2009 and 874/2012: Domestic lighting; incandescent, halogen, and compact fluorescent lamps
- eceee, Updated test report confirms rapid development of LED lamps
- The Guardian, LED lighting surge dimmed by halogen lamp reprieve in Brussels
- CoolProducts EU, Wasteful halogens kept on to please German industry
- ENDS Europe Daily, Research casts doubt on delay to halogen bulb ban
You may like this additional Testing research
Rapid Product Assessment: A New Approach to Testing Productive Use Appliances
VeraSol developed a Rapid Product Assessment approach for the quality evaluation of emerging productive use equipment. The new testing protocol offers a more direct and affordable pathway to verifying the quality of these nascent technologies.
Evaluating Appliance Performance in the Field: Results from Remote Monitoring Solutions Beta Testing
CLASP through Efficiency for Access beta-tested remote performance monitors to develop an ideal solution that monitors the technical performance of solar refrigerators, solar water pumps and solar milking machines in Kenya, Tanzania, Rwanda, Senegal and India.
Off- and Weak-Grid Appliance Market: Nigeria
This country profile covers relevant market and appliance performance data for off-grid appliances sold in Nigeria based on findings from Efficiency for Access market surveys. It provides market insights to help inform sector stakeholders and encourage higher market penetration for high-quality off- and weak-grid appropriate appliances.
Electric Pressure Cooker Usability Testing Buyer’s Guide
This Global LEAP Usability Testing Buyer's Guide contains information about select Winner and Finalist EPCs that participated in a three-month usability testing in Kenya. Testing was conducted as part of the 2020 Global LEAP Awards EPC Competition.
Enabling Reliable Testing Capacity in Southeast Asia
In 2019, CLASP carried out an inter-laboratory comparison exercise in Vietnam—an exercise to assess regional testing capacity of air conditioners and promote more accurate, consistent, and reproducible tests. The Round Robin Testing Report summarizes the RRT exercise findings, analysis results, and recommendations to improve the testing procedures and processes.
Off- and Weak Grid Appliance Market: Sierra Leone
This country profile covers relevant market and appliance performance data for off-grid appliances sold in Sierra Leone based on findings from Efficiency for Access market surveys. The profile explores the overall market landscape in Sierra Leone, the common power type, size, price, and warranty of off-grid appliances sold in retail markets, and other findings relevant to sector stakeholders working in Sierra Leone.
Transitional Test Method for Ecodesign and Energy Labelling requirements for Electronic Displays
Transitional Test Method sets out a measurement methodology that can be freely used by manufacturers and importers of electronic displays to assess compliance with two recent European regulations.
Solar Water Pump Durability Research Memo
This memo fills important knowledge gaps on solar water pump durability by sharing key data from Global LEAP Awards laboratory testing and summarizing information from the existing literature and interviews with industry experts. It provides useful recommendations for how to enhance solar water pump durability and identifies opportunities for how to improve existing test methods and future quality assurance efforts.